this is no contest g36e is best by far! the scar has good ROF and low recoil maybe but i would suggest that only if u were new and learning to play even then if i wanted something with low recoil and good ROF i would pick the m4a1. the g36e has an excellent scope, and also does great damage and a good ROF i would pick the g36e for sure. yea, theres alot of people who say its for noobs but hey if someone calls u a noob for killin them wit it, who won the battle the person whos yelling at you or you; the person who got a kill ? the ak-47 in my opinion is horrible, ive used it several times and it seems my kdr always goes down, it hits high but definitly isnt very reliable, sometimes ul get someone all the way across the course then next time ur bullets wont even touch them, compared to the g36e in CQC and far range its just a bad choice. the g36e is the better all around gun and i would definitly pick it
Sry if that was too long lol! - Hope it helped